Few topics are as controversial among sailors as the quality of the boats we invest in to help realise our dreams of a life afloat.
It is quite extraordinary that these matters receive so little consideration in the sailing press, although the fact that our press has become, willingly or unwillingly, so dependent on its advertisers might perhaps have something to do with it. The transformation of boat building from a craft into an industrial process and, in particular, the implications of this change in terms of the quality and price of the product seem to me to be fundamental issues for our sport and yet they are hardly eating up the column inches. Clearly sailing could never have become widely accessible as a sport without the introduction of mass production in GRP.
When yacht production first began to move onto something approaching an industrial scale, the small number of manufacturers offering boats at shows in Europe could have sold dozens of each model every time they exhibited. Coincidentally it was to Brian that the founder of my company, John Adam, turned in 1968 in his search for something small and seaworthy to win him some respite from excessive strife on the domestic front.
John’s story created a sensation at the time in Germany so that all the marketing professionals in the world could not have coordinated a better market launch for Leisure yachts.
The number of people eager to get afloat was simply too high for traditional production methods and craftsmanship to cope. Henry Ford started exploring the possibilities of assembly line production a century ago, but it would be another 60 years before boat builders first sat up and took notice. Originally the hull of a boat was a very complex assembly: to keel and keelson, stem, sternpost, stringers, deck beams and ribs were added planks as thick as a seaman’s thumb and the whole thing was bolted, nailed and glued together, sealed, sealed and sealed again and then finally treated to several coats of paint to create a thoroughly robust and watertight structure. A finished hull of this nature came ready to sail; there was no need for extra interior structures or fittings to help spread and absorb the working loads.
Rationalizing hull construction was the logical way to go – and it is here that the rot set in!
It is characteristic of the modern classics that although they have a GRP hull, they were still fitted out by craftspeople, that is to say skilled boat builders still had a hand – and earned a crust – in their production. Modern classics enjoy great popularity today because of the way they combine the beautiful lines and traditional craftsmanship of old with modern materials. There is more to boat building than right angles; indeed their very curvaceousness accounts for a big part of the appeal of those striking little ships whose lines alone set hearts pounding and bank accounts quaking. The visual language of traditional design was emotional: function followed form and not vice versa. Interior shells and moulded parts have increasingly driven traditional boat building out of interior construction too on the basis that separate units and components can be mass-produced rapidly and installed inside a bare hull equally quickly.
Today hulls are reinforced in critical areas with bulkheads, interior shells, longitudinal stringers and space frames to make sure that when the boat is lifted out, the keel comes too, that the engine doesn’t slowly make its way up the boat while motoring and that the pressure transmitted from the mast above when sailing close-hauled does not leave hapless crewmembers marooned in the heads. Some would have us believe that modern boats are more solid than ever, but can we really believe that? It is no secret that mast, rigging, sails, engine, keel and rudder pull and push the boat in different directions and that hydraulic systems can put a bend in the hull as well as the mast.
Everyone understands that the half-life of a new stripped-out racing machine is short, that at some none-too-distant point in the future that once proud and resolute bow will begin to acquiesce a little as the sea builds. We should also note that thanks to cheap materials and labour – and the fact that in those days nobody realised just how thin they could go – laminated hulls on older boats and those built in the Far East are often extremely thick. The greatest secret in the increasing industrialization of modern boat building is probably the sharp reduction in production times and concomitant increase in value added. I know of one sailor who, out of love for his wife and in preparation for the big retirement cruise, decided to swap his dark cavern of a steel yacht for a new – and much brighter – alternative. I have seen similar myself in Les Sables d’Olonnes: the project concerned, an imposing new catamaran, was just a week away from delivery and yet there it stood in the middle of the hall, deckless, looking more like a building site than a boat. Neither I, nor the owner and his wife sitting at home in Bavaria with their sea bags packed and poised, could believe everything would be ready on schedule. I always seem to end up comparing money invested in yachts with money spent on property (albeit houses too have their weaknesses with the wind on the nose). It is hardly surprising then that terms like “quality yacht” always seem to be applied to more expensive vessels.
It may be interesting – perhaps shocking – to reflect a little on the hours of work that go into producing a finished yacht.
We are honoured almost every week with the launch of some or other new boat, just about all of them production GRP designs. That such rapid changes of model are even possible is, without exception, down to the enormous rationalization and acceleration of all processes. Building a metal yacht remains a time-consuming business and the preserve mainly of one-offs. If the lively response to the first part of this blog on the German internet forums is anything to go by, this matter may be even more controversial than I suspected: the hornets nest has been stirred, sensitivities have been pricked and unsettled sailors are taking to their keyboards to explain and defend their views and decisions.
I believe proper consideration of these ideas based on a rigorous investigation of whether modern is always better could trigger – or at least sow the seeds of – a seismic shift in the way some sailors think about boats. Some compromises are better than others, however, and what better way to start an exploration of their relative advantages and disadvantages than with the observations of a certain grey-haired character who, though his age might suggest a rather conservative angle, derives his opinions directly from experience and careful reasoning rather than dogma and stubbornness. Although the ideas discussed here relate first and foremost to the yacht intended for longer voyages, it cannot do any harm to reflect on them and how they might apply whatever you have in mind.
Much of the first part of this blog concentrated on the impact of changes in boat building methods, industrialization and value-added considerations in large-scale GRP production on concepts of and approaches to hull construction. I believe that boats were built better in the past essentially because the methods then employed produced a more robust vessel.
It is no accident that modern underwater shapes always include bolt-on extremities in place of the traditional V-form forefoot, guarantor of a smooth ride through waves, good seakeeping and relative peace and quiet down below. A quick glance at the spacing of the rudder bearings and the leverage that can be exerted on them in most modern designs should provide more than enough material for seafaring nightmares.
One Kiwi professional delivery skipper is said to have “worn out” several balanced rudders in the course of taking a European production yacht home to New Zealand. Performance (insofar as it is confused with speed) also has another dark side of which anyone who values the chance to sleep in peace at sea ought to be aware.
When every week brings new models, glowing test reports and more slick marketing to match and when each successive development seems intended only to make us forget what has gone before, it takes a stoical composure to read between the lines and seek out the real purpose of this spiral of gloss. The only way to be sure a boat is really robust and well-built enough for long-term use is to put it to long-term use – or break it trying… However the typical year for most seafarers yet to shed the shackles of the rat race amounts in total to no more than a few weeks under sail in a good year and less than a hundred hours on the engine in a bad year: most boats spend most of their time turning silent, solitary circles around a mooring buoy or staring at an empty car park in the vain hope that today, at long last, the skipper will finally put in an appearance and let them off the leash. I wouldn’t want to put an exact figure on the number of nautical miles required to reach a verdict, but I do think considering the relative merits of different boats in long-term use is a good way of establishing the criteria that really count in practice. A design’s ability to hold its value over time is a key indicator here: any owner whose boat is known to have come up short in the moment of truth can expect to see its resale value evaporate like sea spray on a hot day in the Canaries. Obviously the yachts we turn to as the vehicle of our sailing fantasies in generally show far more endurance than their crew.
We could of course turn a blind eye to stories of trouble at sea, keep our thoughts within our comfort zone and specifically avoid learning just what can happen in extreme conditions. The matter of hull strength we have already done to death and there is nothing to be gained be revisiting it.
Here too the new ‘solution’ fails to measure up to the older ideas it has replaced: commercial shaft drive systems always include a thrust block to pass on the thrust from the shaft, but force transmission in a saildrive system is inherently unfavourable because of the way thrust generated in the basement has to be tamed and transferred a whole level higher up in the structure. The Contessa 32 occupies a special niche in the used boat market thanks to its exceptional build quality.
A few minutes in the company of Google and the usual portals can give a pretty good idea of the market value of used yachts (although it should not be forgotten that there can be a big gap between asking price and actual selling price and selling prices hardly ever become public knowledge). A good reputation, which boosts resale value immeasurably, can only be earned through satisfied customers. It seems rather curious then that while the automotive industry, for example, generally makes no secret of the number of hours of work required to manufacture different cars, the amount of time taken to build a boat never gets an airing in public. Today’s volume manufacturers manage to maintain extensive ranges and unveil new models frequently despite selling but a modest number of each design.
With the price of a new boat now broadly comparable with that of a fairly serious piece of real estate, I do not think it unreasonable to raise the question of just how well today’s craft hold their value.
Some would apparently like us to believe a yacht has a maximum life expectancy after which the scrap heap beckons, but as sailors our heart, our head and our experience all tell us otherwise. Cars, in contrast, begin losing value and integrity to depreciation and rust from the moment they leave the showroom and only the passing of the years reveals which models have the wherewithal to bounce back as classic collector’s items and which go for scrapping ready to do it all again in some other form. How the value of our floating assets evolves in practice largely comes down to build quality, but it’s hard to imagine any sailor accepting that his or her boat would be ‘sailed-out’, as it were, after a certain number of years and then being prepared to accept any price on the grounds that anything is better than nothing for an ‘end-of-life’ product. But back to the matter in hand: the better its quality (which equates more or less to how well it is built), the better a yacht will hold its value. I am sure sailors of all persuasions understand that aluminium hulls are in a completely different league when it comes to build strength and durability. Anyone harbouring any lingering doubts should spend a few minutes browsing the photo archive of insurer PANTAENIUS, which gives a fairly compelling insight into the toughness of boats that fall foul of extreme weather, get too friendly with another boat or otherwise overindulge in off-piste activities.
Almost all of the metal yachts built in Germany come from small-scale builders with little or no production automation, so hull costs alone tend towards the eye-watering and the price of a finished boat is seldom less than staggering. Although Germany has several manufacturers capable of holding their own internationally in the field of production GRP boats, it has seen little if any significant innovation in the production of aluminium hulls. The Dutch have quite a number of yards that have transferred the production methods learned in ship-building to yacht construction: computer systems control the entire process, from lofting whole sections to cutting out the various components (using plasma cutters) and shaping and finishing them, which makes it possible to produce a finished hull with minimal tolerances and very smooth lines.
The traditional frame designs and spacings used in aluminium hull construction of course make it enormously strong too. Aluminium even has advantages over steel, as Jimmy Cornell, who has been around the world with both, neatly summarises: on his steel boat, the paintbrush used for touching up after the bumps and scrapes of harbour life seldom had a chance to dry, whereas errant helms careless enough to make contact with his aluminium hull received nothing but a smile and “Have a nice day!” After ten years and something like 80,000 nautical miles of sailing, his OVNI 430 still looked fresh as the dew and eager to set out adventuring again with her new owner.
Anyone who has seen how production OVNI yachts take shape at the yard in Les Sable d’Olonnes will understand very well how they have come to be so popular. Chatam, Chassiron, Dalu, Damien, Garcia, Levrier de Mer, Madeira, Maracuja, Meta, Romanee, Trireme, Trismus, Trisbal, Reve Tropique, Via: largely unheard of in the wider world, all of these highly robust yachts – some available in steel only, many in steel or aluminium and some in just aluminium – have an extensive history of bluewater voyaging, are lively and long-lived and find themselves much in demand.
German circumnavigators Astrid and Wilhelm Greiff, long-standing friends of Jimmy Cornell and representatives of World Cruising, completed their lap around the world some 20 years ago in a French Via 42, a boat whose builder subsequently ran into financial difficulties when its great attention to detail turned out to be unprofitable. One of the peculiar features of the aluminium boat-building scene is that aluminium boats very seldom make an appearance at boat shows. NORDSEE yachts, all of them built by Dubbel & Jesse on the island of Norderney on the German North Sea coast, enjoy legendary status in Germany and are highly prized in the second-hand market. The way that aluminium and steel boat-building has fallen out of favour in Germany cannot be explained by any lack of demand, but it certainly does take entrepreneurial vision to guide the development of a yard in such a way as to permit the production of attractive yachts from good designers using the latest construction methods at a price customers will be willing to pay. Diese Boote, hier gebaut, aber direkt vom idiotischen europaischen Trend abgeguckt, sind ein schoner Mist, was Verarbeitung und Design angeht. Die Cockpits sind viel zu gross, man kann sich kaum festhalten, alles ist spiegelglatt, Einen Spiegel gibt es auch nicht mehr, wenn etwas in Richtung Heck rutscht, incl.
Das Unterwasseeschiff ist vom Bug bis zum Hech flach und gerade, und geben deshalb den Booten miserable Seeigenschaften bei etwas Seegang. Mein Boot ist ein umgebauter Kielzugvogel, aus Holz 38 Jahre alt, aber er fahrt allen 20 bis 23 Fuss langen Booten davon, alten und nagelneuen. The 20ft Roger Dongray-designed Golant Ketch shown above was built by Boat Building Academy student Keith McIlwain on the BBA’s long course. Daydream, the largest boat built by the BBA’s October 2013 intake, is a decked trailer sailer with lifting centreboard, outboard engine and cabin. From Bristol, Keith started his working life as a sailmaker and worked his way up to loft manager for a premier sail company before starting a career in sales and marketing.
He decided to join the 38-week course as a way of returning to the boating industry with a new career, and is currently setting up his own boat building, restoration and repairs business just outside of Bristol, to be called Daydream Boats. Keith will build on his prior experience of furniture and sail-making, and will also be an agent for Jeckells Sails in the South West.
He chose to build the Golant Ketch as he wanted a boat he could sail around Bristol and the South West, and to help promote his business to potential customers. Brenton moved to the UK with his family in 2005 and worked for an aircraft maintenance company. He is currently working with former academy instructor, Justin Adkin at his workshop based in Axminster and in the future will consider options in boat building, woodworking and furniture making.
Students Andy Jones, George Le Gallais and Steven Roberts also worked closely with Keith to build Daydream, but between them also made a 14ft paddleboard, again shown in the gallery above . The plans for the ply on frame Kaholo board were purchased from Chesapeake Light Craft website. Andy who grew up in Lyme Regis, joined the Academy from London where he worked for Babcock Critical Services in partnership with the London and Lincolnshire fire and rescue brigades.
Joe who loves to experience different cultures and to throw himself into unfamiliar territory, spent time travelling around Europe, North and South America, Australia and India before joining the Academy. Joe from Devon has work lined up at the Underfall Boatyard in Bristol, and Andy is working at Sutton Oars in Teignmouth, making wooden oars for gigs, and carbon skull oars.
Have you got news for us?If what you're doing is like the things you read about here - please write and tell us what you're up to. Classic Sailor is a new magazine about traditional and classic boats from ex-Classic Boat editor Dan Houston and colleagues that promises rather more coverage of the traditional craft around our coast. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Follow me on TwitterLooking for something?This is a busy weblog, and what you're looking for is probably still here - just a little way down the list now. Our Faversham-based friend Alan Thorne can help with boatbuilding projects - constructing to plans in very tidy stitch-and-glue or more traditional techniques. Marine engine installation and repair are part of the curriculum at The Boat School in Eastport, Maine. Last spring, Husson University decided to halt classes at The Boat School in Eastport, Maine, as of graduation day 2012. Husson's decision was not received well by a lot of us at The Boat School, and it put in to motion a plan to keep the Boat School alive by a handful of alumni, industry members, and The Friends of the Boat School. As of December 1, 2011, The Friends of The Boat School became the owners of the property and have permission from the state to start classes in September. All those involved with the school know what a wonderful asset The Friends of The Boat School is, and it is because of this not-for-profit, volunteer-only organization that the new school will exist.
Maine's Marine Technology Center, 16 Deep Cove Road, Eastport, ME 04631 or call 207-853-0990.
For information about recruitment and for a presentation at a school or business, please contact Bob Turcotte, Turcotte Yacht Design, LLC, 12 Hagar Drive, Topsham, ME 04086 or call 207-729-7486. USHarbors delivers free, printable tide charts, onshore and marine forecasts, buoy data, weather radar, a steady stream of local knowledge, and a directory of coastal businesses. Former students came, bringing the boats they’ve been working on since leaving the course.
Then it was all back to Lyme Regis for the end of the September course, celebrated by the course boat launch in Lyme Regis harbour and a barbecue on the beach on Thursday 12th. We spent two days in picturesque Cape May, waiting out the predicted southerly gale, before setting off again. The Tidewater Yacht Marina is near the location of "Mile Marker Zero" which is considered to be the gateway to the Intracoastal Waterway (ICW). The Elizabeth River separates Portsmouth from Norfolk, and Friday we took the ferry across from our marina to Norfolk, where Ferdi and I visited the battleship USS Wisconsin, the biggest and last battleship ever built by the US Navy - it once carried a crew of 2 700 sailors! After a week of miscellaneous boat repairs and restocking, we left Sandy Hook on Saturday, 13 December at around 1.30pm.
Our night watches were pretty exhausting, especially for Ferdi (who had to keep navigating even when it wasn't his watch), since the sea was fairly choppy and temperatures way below zero (-6°C without wind chill). In the morning, after another spectacular sunrise, we listened to one of the marine weather reports on the VHF radio and decided (prudent mariners that we are) to cut our planned voyage short and stop over at Cape May, NJ instead of Norfolk.


Eventually we were safely in the harbour and slowly motored towards the marina down Schellenger Creek. Baie jaloers van hierdie kant af - gemoedere loop maar hoog hier op kantoor, almal afgerem, gedaan en naar met mekaar. We finally got a weather gap on Friday, 5 December and set sail from Bristol Marine at around noon on a clear, calm but cold day.
We (Ferdi, Wimpie and I) were heading for Sandy Hook in New Jersey (part of the greater New York metropolitan area), since we had decided the weather was just too unpredictable to try and make it to Fort Lauderdale in one go. So it was quite a long night through a choppy sea with south-westerly winds of 10 to 15 knots. About two hours before dawn the ocean calmed down considerably and gliding across an oily sea, we were able to witness the most incredible sunrise - the kind of experience that makes it all worthwhile!
After a while, Wimpie came out to steer and Ferdi and I went below and made us a fabulous sausage and egg breakfast. Around 4pm on Saturday and about 28 hours after we set off from Bristol, Ferdi navigated us through a narrow channel into Sandy Hook, a town just to the south-west of New York, where we berthed at the Atlantic Highlands Municipal Harbor.
On Sunday, our first morning in Sandy Hook, we woke up to find it had snowed during the night.
Towards evening, the wind picked up considerably and Strider was straining at her mooring lines. So we are still in Rhode Island, but big news - after almost a year on the hard, Strider was put to water on Tuesday. We still have a few more tasks to complete on board, but are hoping to set sail for Fort Lauderdale (and warmer climes!) within the next week as soon as the right weather opportunity presents itself. Bon Voyage, Ferdi and Marguerite, we wish you the best and hope to see you on the seas someday! We are really looking forward to receiving the family and friends who have promised to come sailing with us at various stages of our circumnavigation.
Obviously, choosing a boat ranks as one of the key decisions for any sailor: a choice that proves to have been a poor one can have serious and far-reaching consequences – and is by no means straightforward (or inexpensive) to rectify.
Our would-be critics have simply washed their hands of the whole notion of quality, with any criticism limited to fairly trivial points such as headroom, berth length and interior furnishing.
The smaller the boat, the bigger the potential market open to it and hence the more units to be sold.
The Seventies and Eighties were gold rush time as sailors beat a path to the boatyard gates and demand soared. Armed with a Leisure 17, he headed West and eventually found himself on the beach in Cuba having fallen asleep and run aground.
The brand retains a special aura to this day, with over 4000 Leisures sold and almost all of them still in existence. Consumers were no more patient then than they are now: once they felt the itch, they wanted deck beneath their feet and pronto. To keep the weight down, racing yachts often started life with nothing below but pipe berths and were only fully furnished at a later date if and when racing gave way to luxury cruising. Once a female mould had been engineered, ready-made boat shells could be turned out one after the other like so many bread rolls in a process that suddenly no longer needed the expertise of skilled boat builders. Also no secret is the fact that older GRP boats tend to be considerably more solid, because stringers, bearers and wooden interior components are all laminated into the hull. They were always perfectly quiet to sail even in a good breeze and the deck never creaked even when the summer hoards stampeded across on their way from the far end of the raft to the bar.
And, at a more basic level, because of the way they allow families – even those members with a more sensitive nose – to take to the sea without the damp reek of stale air and musty socks that tends to pervade the more traditional of traditional craft. On a more practical level, it also makes sure that no matter how soundly you slept, you quickly remember that you are on the boat and not in the house. Today the mainstream marches to the beat of a different drummer, with aesthetic concept and product shaped by marketing diktats and design vocabulary serving only to ensure brand recognition and distinctiveness.
They had a backbone and ribs, meaning they were better armed against ramming, stranding, grounding and other extreme encounters, and carried their rudder firmly mounted and safely tucked away in the sweet spot at the trailing edge of the keel.
Space has become a more compelling argument and the obvious response has been to do away with the traditional foundation of a strong hull – its frame and ribs – without putting anything obvious in its place. Only a stiff hull can endure such loads in the long term; once flexing sets in, serious problems are sure to follow. Life is a compromise – and when it comes to rig tension, it can be a fine line between just right and ever so slightly too much.
Or, to put it another way, why do international investors and the pin-striped locusts suddenly have yacht manufacturers in their sights?
Keen to be, as it were, in the delivery room to witness the arrival of his new home from home, he cheerfully turned up one Monday morning at the yard appointed to realise his dreams expecting to witness the final stages of fitting out.
In Germany, a new family house in a pleasant setting costs in the region of €200,000 and represents thousands of man hours at a moderate level of value added for all of the companies involved. The conclusions in terms of the inherent value of any given boat soon become perfectly clear: you do indeed get what you pay for (in more ways than one). This speaks of serious rationalization on a scale unknown – perhaps even inconceivable – to ordinary sailors. A high-quality 45-foot custom boat in aluminium might take around 5000 hours to build; a GRP equivalent of the same size would almost certainly be ready to hit the water in a fraction of this time. I would say that one could write heavy books on the subject of these deliberations, but as it happens, most of these books – presenting a variety of perspectives – are already out there. My expertise lies in self-steering and in helping yachtsman and yachtswomen gain a little respite from the tiller or wheel at sea. Trying to phrase the arguments involved in simple black and white terms serves no purpose in the same way that no one material can always be the right choice for every boat: just as GRP has its osmosis, aluminium its electrolysis and welded steel its rust, so the plank has its worm. Knowledge is a valuable commodity and one it’s hard to have too much of when looking for a new home on the seas. Sailors are dreamers and their dreams – irrespective of whether they ever come to fruition – almost always revolve around open water and distant islands and it consequently makes sense to consider how the picture may have changed over the years in terms of the quality, robustness and price of the great proliferation of production yachts in which we are now invited to trust. Today’s production GRP yachts have become far removed from the traditional understanding of what a hull should be and how it acquires its strength. And in those days hull, keel and rudder formed a single strong unit, which is always a plus in my eyes. A spade rudder is certainly efficient in form and effect, but it also makes a tremendous lever and experience suggests the force applied at the bottom at times exceeds the strength of the mounting structure at the top. Stories of problems with keels and rudders fill an increasing proportion of the nautical press – although, since they tend to affect solo sailors with the necessary wit to find their own way home, they seldom make headlines outside of the sphere of sailing. The number of sailors quickly and quietly trading in their fast rides for better all-around offshore performers is rising rapidly.
Of course, but there are plenty more where they came from and they tell a consistent story – a story even ordinary sailors who do not spend their whole life at sea would do well to heed if they really want to be able to trust in their boat. It is self-evident that yachts used for bluewater voyaging have to withstand far greater loads than fair-weather weekenders. Boats become permanently unsalable if the nautical community gets wind of any serious weaknesses.
When conditions deteriorate, the great majority of sailors head straight for the nearest port, teeth clenched, without ever giving the storm sails a chance to shine.
This approach, I would suggest, is likely to be more popular among those who have reason to fear their own judgment: it cannot be a nice feeling to buy a boat for one set of reasons and then fall out of love with it on other, far more compelling grounds. This is quite different to the situation with a conventional drive, which transmits its propulsive force to the backbone of the vessel in a straight line and, of course, enjoys a protected location tucked in at the trailing edge of the keel.
Just about every reputable brand operates an Owners’ Association (albeit a few find the temptation to use it mainly as a marketing platform for new models hard to resist). Take an example with a lifetime of use (30 to 40 years in many cases) already behind it, send it for a full refit with the original builder and you have a boat as good as new ready for another lifetime of adventures. That today’s market is a difficult place even for high-quality yachts from respected yards is evident from the way so many pre-owned examples take such a long time to find a new home. Second-hand KOOPMANS yachts, for example, regularly command excellent prices – irrespective of hull material – and are commonly snapped up almost as soon as they become available.
Word of mouth recommendations are becoming increasingly important for manufacturers today: full-page glossy adverts carry little weight if the people who actually sail the boats featured are left unimpressed. We have to content ourselves with speculation – and we speculate that it probably does not take very long at all. We can deduce from this that, thanks to modern moulding techniques, they do not have to shift many units of a new product before moving into profit.
While marketing can affect this to an extent, sailors are very well attuned to more concrete factors – notably the quality of their floating beauties as verified in long-term use and, of course, simple supply and demand – and it tends to be these that determine the price for which pre-loved (or not) boats eventually change hands. However finding a potential buyer with a similar view of worth is proving especially difficult for many sellers at the moment and while those of stout heart can usually manage a polite refusal, responding to a perceived derisory offer for a boat in which you have invested so much of yourself can be a painful business (such situations are handled more dispassionately in the USA, where sellers seem able to accept or refuse offers freely without any sense of personal insult – emotions play no role here and tears are seldom shed).
The venerable old-timers already enjoy a strong market and the new classics are following a similar path. One-offs aside, Germany is quite insignificant internationally as a producer of aluminium yachts; in fact the only German company to have achieved significant numbers is Reinke, whose hard chine designs can also be built by fearless DIY-ers (just how many projects there are languishing half-finished at the end of gardens all over Germany after would-be boat-owners found the work harder than anticipated, the costs more than they could stomach or the looming prospect of divorce too unattractive to contemplate nobody knows, but it’s likely to be more than a few). The result is yachts with a perfect surface finish that need no more than sand-blasting; filling and painting are seldom required.
Even grounding, encounters with ice and other sleepless-night-inducing impact scenarios need not necessarily be a problem for a well-found aluminium yacht.
They are only moderately more expensive, relatively-speaking, than GRP boats, demand and lead times are enormous and the second-hand market is quite stable, as if there had been no financial crisis at all.
Via centreboarders, with their skeg- and heel-mounted rudder, are today a highly sought-after rarity. Few ever come up for sale, however: once acquired, they tend to become family heirlooms, with successive generations of sailors appreciating their outstanding quality and building a firm conviction that after this, any other boat would be a backwards step. The Dutch have a thriving and technologically advanced boat-building industry capable of fabricating eye-catching vessels at a reasonable price, so it is no wonder we immediately look to our tulip-raising neighbours whenever the conversation turns to metal yachts. Diese heutigen Fahrtenboote haben alle, ein viel zu breites Heck, dass zwei Ruder braucht, weil der Ruderganger mit einem Mittschiffsruder vorn nichts sieht. Mochte gerne wissen wo in den letzten Jahren der Fortschritt im Fahrtenbootsbau geblieben ist.
He joined the Academy to start a career in boat building, and throughout the course has particularly enjoyed developing his woodworking skills. It was sheathed in glass and epoxy; to paddle it the students use paddles they built as part of the course. During the course he worked on all of the boat projects, in particular Keith’s Golant Ketch, to which he became quite attached. Like Andy and all 38-week course students Joe worked on all of the course boat projects and enjoyed learning modern and traditional techniques.
Try scrolling down, clicking on the 'older posts' button at the bottom of this page - or try the search gadget!
As a result of this decision, the school did not take on a freshman class for the upcoming fall semester.
During this time, some odd jobs were done on the boat, and we got our warm clothes washed and dried. This time I made sure everything on board was safely secured, but the Cape May inlet was kind to us on our way out and we got through without much fuss.
Once inside the bay, it took us around three hours to reach our destination, Tidewater Yacht Marina in Portsmouth on the Elizabeth River.
Upon approaching our mooring, our beloved Strider was as wilfull as her namesake back in Wilderness - she flatly refused to engage in reverse gear, which led to an almost close encounter with a moored neighbour. Since we are planning to continue our voyage along the ICW for some part of the way (at least to Cape Hatteras), this is the perfect spot for us to regroup and make use of local knowledge of the route ahead. Exiting our wooden pile slip at low tide and with gusty winds tending to push Strider towards the dock was a bit tricky and we had to sacrifice a mooring line in the process. It was a moonlit night (a day after full moon) and on one of my watches I saw at least eight shooting stars! A gale was predicted for Sunday night, but instead of helping us along from behind, we would be heading straight into it.
One of our guide books says the Cape May inlet is "one of the safest inlets along the New Jersey coast, but occasionally the wind and tide conspire to produce the 'inlet effect', a disturbing chop in the area around the breakwaters".
The second leg of our voyage down the east coast of the US had taken around 24 hours (we are now about 350 Nm from Bristol, RI, our starting point). Towards evening on Friday, Strider gave us a challenge - the batteries were discharging far too rapidly for the captain's comfort. The three of us took it in turns to stand watch and steer, with Ferdi taking the brunt of it. I should mention here that NONE of us had been even slightly seasick for the whole journey!
Needless to say, we didn't mess about much, after a quick supper we collapsed in our cabins and slept like logs. Later it was gusting 57 knots and Ferdi got up several times during the night to adjust the lines. Soos op epos gese ek is ongelooflik trots en jaloers op julle geleentheid en sense of adventure - briljante lewens ondervindign en ek hoop M dat jy n boek sal uitbring en dalk n ander nering kry as travel writer - a year in provence - of so iets. Yes, yes, our previous blog entry said we were leaving at the end of October, but fixing up a boat is like building a house - the project is of course never completed when you think it will be!
We moved her from the warehouse in Franklin Street to Bristol Marine nearby two weeks ago and have since been doing various restoration jobs and fitting new electronics and other must-haves on board. Strider is currently resting in Bristol, RI and the final preparations are underway for her to become our home for the next few years.
Without wanting to sound too prescriptive, here are some suggestions on what to bring and what should preferably stay at home (some of these may be obvious, but some I had to learn the hard way!). Almost half the clothes I had initially brought to the US, got sent back to SA before we set sail! We can in no way guarantee that we will arrive at or depart from a particular destination on a particular day. Take on too much of a financial burden, leave yourself too much to learn or trust too much to your own handiwork and you could end up in trouble, especially if the press-ganged family, left at the mercy of your orders from the bridge, also has to live with your misjudgements as immortalised in composite, aluminium or steel. The fundamental properties of a product as a seagoing vessel are seldom even considered, let alone subjected to a rigorous comparative investigation. Optimists and Lasers have been churned out in their millions, or least hundreds of thousands, and while yachts have never shifted in these numbers, their extra features – everything from heads to an engine – make them much more interesting in terms of the value to be extracted per unit. Brian Meerlow and his team in England built thousands of their Leisure yachts, for example, back when nobody worried about breathing in styrene vapour and extractors were unheard of.
It was while cooling his heels in one of Castro’s prisons that he made the decision to set up Windpilot: the first vane gear had after all passed its test with flying colours (keeping watch – then as now – not being a part of its remit). When it comes to impatience, children on Christmas Eve have nothing on grown men and women waiting for a new boat to arrive. Whether to hit the race course with a crack crew or embark family and friends and concentrate on seeing and being seen was a matter for the owner: the yachts were tough enough for both lives – in fact they still are.
The resulting structure is very stable, especially since the stringers and bearers are bonded face-on and the interior components edge-on. Rights angles really were an unusual sight in this era, which for me explains much of its charm and elegance. Moulded components can also incorporate rounded edges and corners at no extra cost to suggest at least a token element of design flair.


Sailors flock to the resulting space(ous) ships like moths to a candle, for it seems the number of berths has become the measure of all things (and has a not insignificant effect on the price).
Although … once I saw a sailing boat at one of the big boat shows that had been sliced in half longitudinally and I couldn’t help noticing just how little substance there would be between the sailor asleep in a bunk of a heeling yacht and the fish swimming past outside. Signs of fatigue on the hull, keel and rudder, soon our constant companions, auger well for the repair and restoration business.
A production GRP yacht costing a similar amount takes a fraction of the time to create – and is then very often compared in price terms to boats whose construction involves a much larger element of craftsmanship. It can also be interesting to look at the second-hand market and see how perceptions of quality and value change once long-term use has had a chance to expose weaknesses not apparent on the boat show floor. Nevertheless even the biggest yards with global marketing and a lively charter supply business still achieve only modest output when compared with the producers of other high-priced goods, which probably explains the breathless pace of competition: production yachts have to be introduced, promoted and phased out again faster than cars just to keep up the pressure on the other big players in the market. The GRP version would surely be significantly cheaper too, so it wins hands down – unless, perhaps, other factors like seaworthiness, safety, reliability, suitability for bluewater sailing, performance in use, value-holding ability and ease of resale also come into the equation. Lucky indeed the sailor who manages to plot a smooth passage through these treacherous waters and find a boat that lives up to expectations even after the trials of long-term use.
Traditional structures are not necessarily the only solution, but the sense of security their solidity conveys is certainly a nice feeling. The hull of the typical modern production GRP yacht (I will look at metal hulls another time) consists of just a shell.
The gung-ho yachtsman can imagine nothing worse than being passed to lee by a bathtub and inherent strength is the asset many seem willing to sacrifice – at times apparently without even beginning to consider the consequences – on the altar of vanity.
Not everyone can walk on water and those of us who can’t might do well to avoid knowingly putting ourselves in this situation rather than just trusting the sat phone, EPIRB and shortwave radio to buy us a second bite at the cherry. One seafaring family recently sold their brand new yacht in a hurry at the end of its first bash across the Atlantic, preferring instead to continue their planned trip around the world with a 40-year old classic. The open ocean, of course, has no monopoly on uncomfortable conditions: the combination of strong winds, powerful currents and prominent landforms can put yachts to the test even close to home. Older boats still making their way under sail have proved they can last the distance: novelty in and of itself is no reason suddenly to consign them to the yacht cemetery!
Strongly tidal waters and the higher latitudes also have their challenges I concede, but we cannot penetrate to the heart of the matter without considering proper long-term offshore exposure. The more unpleasant memories tend to fade quickly, especially away from the water, and soon enough bad times have been reborn as great stories and it’s time to get back afloat.
A saildrive, for example, which leaves the crew parted from the fishes by just a few millimetres of gasket, can prove the Achilles’ heel of an otherwise robust yacht. The difference in terms of the work involved in installation and alignment between a conventional shaft system and a saildrive amounts to many hours – too many hours for the major production boatbuilders to ignore.
The classifieds pages of leading sailing magazines contain innumerable repeat ads, with boats commonly taking several years to sell despite being advertised with good photos and plenty of detail.
OVNI, GARCIA, BESTEVAER, VAN DE STADT, HUTTING and other aluminium yachts also often seem to change hands quickly with little fanfare at a price strong enough to spare seller’s blushes. Also striking is the fact that while modern production yachts progress through the yard very much faster than their predecessors, the price we pay for them has not fallen at the same rapid rate. Mass-produced GRP yachts, in contrast, are available in huge numbers second hand, in most cases at broadly similar prices, but sales have become increasingly rare and the market has just about ground to a halt. Self-build projects offer little prospect of adding value, as no matter how well they may have performed in use, home-made boats always bear the stigma of amateur construction and the associated fear that perhaps not everything has ended up quite as it should.
The fact that hulls built in seawater-resistant 5083 grade aluminium do not even need painting means they are ideally prepared for the knocks and dings of everyday use – and further underlines just how different they are to modern eggshell-thin GRP equivalents, which have little in the way of load-bearing structure and seem decidedly fragile by comparison. France has always produced a large number of aluminium yachts, in part perhaps because Eric Tabarly adopted the material early on for his Pen Duicks, but also because French yachtsmen and -women tend to sail more, harder and in tougher conditions. It’s not as if the yards are short of orders… While this alone speaks volumes, it is also probably worth mentioning again that the cost of attending boat shows, like other marketing and sales costs, passes straight into the purchase price.
Unfortunately the production of Nordsee yachts ended with the tragic death of one of the yard’s proprietors, Herr Dubbel, and today BENJAMINS in Emden, close to the Dutch border, is probably one of the few German yards still building aluminium yachts professionally in any significant numbers. Visit Kooi in Makkum or Koopmans in Sneek and see just how professionally they go about their work and I think you will immediately appreciate why those who sail them have no hesitation in giving these wonderfully robust yachts their full trust right from day one. Die Massenpresse will heute uns allen wahrmachen, dass alles was ein Designer geschaffen hat, etwas besonders wertvolles(teures) ist. Dann werden die Kaufer genauer hinschauen und vergleichen – und erschrocken feststellen, dass die Ware nicht immer halt, was der Preis zu versprechen vorgibt. It is felt that at this is time; the school needs to be its own entity and to serve industry not academia. Recruitment is now underway, so you will see us at some of the upcoming boat shows here and out of state as well as the technical high schools.
To join the Friends of The Boat School, contact Tom or Jean Ries at 207-853-4709 or email them by clicking here. Ferdi and I rented a car and went to nearby Atlantic City, the city on which the game of Monopoly was based by a jobless salesman in 1935. It was a relatively uneventful night, much warmer than the leg to Cape May (minimum around 3°C). He had a hard time of putting it together however, since the early hours brought a quartering sea which produced a corkscrew effect on the boat, uncomfortable to say the least for anyone below deck.
The Hampton Roads inside the Chesapeake is one of the busiest shipping lanes in the world, so Ferdi steered us most of the way in order to stay out of the way of barges, naval vessels, freighters and several small fishing vessels. Fortunately, thanks to Wimpie's quick action with the roving fender and bar a negligable scrape, there was no damage all round and we docked without further incident. This 887 ft, 57 000 ton vessel was last used in 1991 in Operation Desert Storm but has also seen active duty in WW11 as well as the Korean War.
We had one hairy experience in that a large fishing trawler came straight for us without any apparent intention of missing us. It took us a good few hours to sail out of Narraganset Bay, with Pell Bridge (connecting Aquidneck Island to Jamestown) receding further and further into the distance every hour. We started with two-hour watches but this later turned to one-hour sessions due to the cold weather (well below freezing, with the wind-chill factor making it much worse!).
Perhaps it was the Stugeron we took (or the pressure-point wristbands I was wearing), but we all found our sealegs very quickly.
According to a local radio weather report it was -6°C but with the wind chill factor this easily became around -18°C!
Thanks to Tom, a most helpful and friendly local marine electrician, the problem was quickly sorted out. On Tuesday at 7am, in below-zero temperatures, her mast and rigging finally went up, after which a travelift gently lowered her into the water (see pics of the event in the photo gallery). Nie veel van 'n kans om julle te join met twee kinders, twee honde, 'n Garfield kat, 'n pappegaai, 'n kokketiel en 'n slang nie! A wise choice right at the beginning can make all the difference in the world to the fun to be had under sail, so it seems astonishing that so many of the issues involved are so seldom properly discussed. The transformation in the nature of boat building precipitated by these pressures was dramatic. In those days the cost of the hull made up an eye-watering proportion of the overall price of the boat.
It has been spirited away to be replaced, here and there, with other structural members in much the same way that many car manufacturers have done away with any distinct chassis to leave each individual component apparently supported only by the parts around it.
He was astonished – and never more so than when the finished boat was handed over right on time just a few days later. True quality reveals itself only in long-term use and it is no surprise the sailor’s brain spends a long time quietly accumulating information before eventually coming to a judgment for or against a particular brand. A design lasts just a few hundred units before the focus moves on and the next contender sets sail.
The fact that after several decades in the business and dozens of boats of my own, I find my conversations with a global sailing community increasingly focusing on boats as such rather than ‘just’ the choice of windvane, has helped to keep my job stimulating and has led me in the process to develop a particular point of view.
Keels are manufactured separately and then bolted on, which is both practical – from the manufacturer’s perspective at least – and reduces costs. Why else would it be that more and more offshore events, even those organised primarily for cruisers, are making it mandatory for participants to carry an emergency rudder in order to spare the rescue helicopter the need to launch every time a steering cable jumps off a block? This, of course, is all part of the charm of our sport, but it does nothing to alter the fact that most boats are only very seldom really put to the test. Saildrives have insidiously worked their way aboard all kinds of designs now thanks to the fact that they are much quicker for the yards to install, but they remain a matter of concern among insurers and have proven by and large to be a retrograde step in the long run for us sailors. For sailors, however, the case is not so clear cut: while a leaking stern tube is certainly annoying, it is nothing compared to some of the problems encountered with a saildrive.
The same cannot be said at the moment for many of the more common modern production yachts, whose resale prices are seriously compromised by the sheer volume of options available in the second-hand market.
Brokers have no magic power to speed up the process either – in fact there is often little they can do other than add yachts to their own listings and advertisements. The stand-out performer among the GRP builders meanwhile is BREEHORN, whose Koopmans-designed boats are purchased almost exclusively by private buyers and are in most cases used for long-distance and offshore sailing. We more or less take it as gospel that in the long term, the price of a home in bricks and mortar moves in one direction only: upwards. Building a boat represents a much more complex undertaking than something like building a house and many sailors have found their self-build dreams in tatters sooner or later because they embarked on the adventure without having had the scale of the task made clear to them. Hence a manufacturer that can market its yachts effectively without having to stump up for boat shows can put more of its revenue into delivering a high-quality product. Skorpion yachts from the FELTZ YACHT in Hamburg also have a solid reputation in the bluewater community. As we all know none of us are getting any younger and we need new blood to carry on the boat building tradition here in Maine.
The history of the school is that it produces professional technicians for the marine businesses here in Maine and elsewhere, so it only makes sense to have it be for the industry.
The tuition has been kept affordable and we are looking forward to classes in September of this year. We visited one of the huge casino's for which the place is famous (both Donald Trump and Sol Kerzner have interests here), but after losing a couple of dollars and deciding we had had enough of glitz and bright lights we headed back to our marina. We motored just outside the designated channel, which took us though the Chesapeake Bay bridge-tunnel, which heads under the surface through the bay, leaving an opening for boaters. The next day we had to look into the cause of the gear malfunction however - always something on a boat!
Seeing those teak decks (6 acres in total) put quite a few things in perspective for Strider's crew! Late afternoon, we hoisted the genoa and sailed on a beam reach, but disappointingly only for a few hours, since the wind turned southerly.
Bit nerve wracking to see both green and red navigation lights bearing down on you at considerable speed!
So we phoned up some marinas in Cape May, and the South Jersey Marina at the south end of the Cape May Harbor was able to accommodate our relatively deep draft. The captain had a helluva time steering us through a narrow inlet with treacherous rocks on either side, with raging, criss-crossing currents and waves causing Strider to heel at least 50° from side to side. So, to save battery power we had to disconnect the power-gobbling autopilot and steer manually the rest of the way - about 18 hours! For those trying to nod off below deck, it was not much warmer and we slept in our foul-weather gear.
We could see the New York skyline in the distance to starboard, with the unmistakable Empire State building towering over the city. The process was – almost literally – turned upside down (or inside out, depending on your point of view) and ever since, boats have been built the wrong way around: today everything starts with the skin and not the bones. Boat builders were craftsmen, not magicians, and bending wood takes time (although of course man hours were not at all expensive in that era). Who seriously spends any time thinking about how much – if any – effective load-bearing structure there is behind that smart interior shell?
The implications of the shell approach for bonds, joins, seaworthiness and endurance are widely understood. While this may be good for the manufacturers (nobody likes complaints), it does increase the risk of sailors only discovering the true limitations – and absolute limits – of their vessel once it is too late to find an easy way out.
As elsewhere, market activity and prices depend on the balance of supply and demand, with excess demand pushing up prices and enabling sellers of the most coveted models to walk that little bit taller on the way to the bank. Their seakeeping, construction and robustness have elevated Koopmans yachts in the European market to a position similar to that once occupied by Sparkman & Stephens.
For months my head has been absorbing scarcely believable facts about boat sales and the prices actually paid for thoroughly respectable yachts. A true nation of seafarers, the French, seadogs and landlubbers alike, revel in the record-breaking exploits of their sailors and turn out in huge numbers to support and honour the country’s nautical heroes with a passion reserved in most other countries only for football. Feltz still works in both aluminium and steel, although most of its business in recent years has come from public authorities and the commercial shipping sector.
At one point I was steering but handed over to the captain since this inexperienced crew member felt decidedly uncomfortable with the massive US Navy ship flanked by two accompanying smaller vessels seemingly bearing down on us from behind.
So again we motored for most of the way, on a route about 5 Nm from the coast, passing Atlantic City with its bright lights and casinos, Egg Harbor and Wildwood with its giant amusement park and ferris wheels clearly visible. Ferdi had to do some nifty steering to get around the vessel, which sped along afterwards seemingly unperturbed.
In a confused sea, with waves coming from all directions, we literally surfed down the inlet.
We spent the rest of the day doing odd jobs on the boat, catching an afternoon nap later on. If there are more sellers than buyers (say, for example, the market becomes flooded with retired charter yachts), however, boats will only sell, if at all, at a substantial discount. These are good times indeed for sailors on the hunt for the perfect steed: buyers reign supreme.
Haben Sie auf einem Designerstuhl gesessen, mussen Sie im ein paar Minuten wieder aufstehen, so unbequem sind sie. We geared down to let it pass and eventually followed it down the Elizabeth River at a safe distance until it turned into a mooring at the naval base to our port side (the 4 300 acre Naval Station Norfolk is the biggest in the world).
I was down below at the time, being thrown from one side of the boat to the other, while at the same time trying to keep the cabin and galley closets closed and preventing our stuff from crashing about (lesson - some of our closet fasteners need looking at) .
Fortunately there was not too much traffic to confuse the two novices on board, but the captain was called upon on occasion to interpret the light signals from other vessels. It was an overcast, foggy night, so no moon and stars, and it wasn't always easy to spot other vessels (not that there were many). Wimpie, who was doing his best to stay in the cockpit, said afterwards some local fishermen on the side banks actually put down their rods to watch the spectacle. Extraordinarily, the market for aluminium yachts seems to march to the beat of a different drummer entirely. On one of my watches (the weather allowed us two hours each this time), I was jolted out of reverie by a dark shape that suddenly appeared metres from Strider on our starboard side - we only just missed a completely unlit marker beacon about 6 Nm from the Delaware coast!



How to make a paper viking longboat races
Speed boat rentals nj shore line
Used dual axle boat trailer sale adelaide