Where is penn station new york city 80s,side dump rail cars for sale uk,new york big bus tour promo code,kansas city southern ho scale locomotives names - Good Point

admin 01.10.2013

A few months ago I got some advice from a classmate who was a year ahead of me, and in the process of finishing up his own M.Arch. As you no doubt know, the original McKim Mead and White structure was demolished fifty years ago this year, despite outrage from preservationists and the design community. The Municipal Art Society of New York recently invited four firms to submit their own ideas for the future of Penn Station and its environs.
Obviously that's a lot for one person to tackle for a thesis, so I'll necessarily have to narrow the focus. 1) Tying together diverse transportation modes (intercity rail, commuter rail, subway, bus, taxi, bike, pedestrian) and other functions (retail, dining, etc.) into a cohesive whole with intuitive, self-evident circulation pathways. 2) The sequence of spaces encountered by arriving and departing passengers, and their phenomenological aspects. 3) Creation of an iconic urban space that serves as an appropriate entry foyer for New York City. 4) How to appropriately pay homage to the original structure and memorialize what was lost, while resisting the knee-jerk impulse to replicate it. SHoP's proposal is the best, not only because it's the most buildable, but also because it's the best at connecting the fabric of the city to Penn. DS+R's proposal seems under cooked - they might have been too focused on finishing their most recent book, and dealing with other, more likely constructable schemes.
SOM's and DS+R's schemes, while visually compelling (DS+R certainly cranked their Rhino machine up to 11) have the air of a purely academic project that was never meant to be actually built. Is critiquing the four proposals a part of the thesis - maybe part of your research - or is the thesis just to do the project? You've been interested in transit for so long it only makes sense that your thesis be transit-related.
It's been interesting watching the reaction to the MAS presentation among some of the bloggers I follow, most of whom are transit advocates, urbanists, and urban planners rather than architects. Then there are the more pragmatic types, who want to see Penn Station upgraded, but their idea of an "upgrade" (which is never really defined) is always completely divorced from architectural questions, as if the architecture is just window dressing that gets applied after the fact. To them, I'd argue that the questions of functionality as a transportation facility is at its heart an architectural question.
That said, I'm particularly drawn to SHoP's proposal, and may use that as a starting point. As for looking at a smaller city, my original thesis idea was to design a new concourse for Cincinnati's historic Union Terminal to replace the one that had been demolished in the 1970's, and some other improvements that would've tied into what I designed for my undergrad thesis which was basically a rapid transit master plan for Cincinnati.
Also, I've spent the past four years heavily invested in Cincinnati's transit advocacy scene, and to be frank, I'm pretty tired of it all.
In short, I find myself much more passionate about Penn Station's challenges and opportunities than about Union Terminal's.
You seemed to indicate that you weren't particularly interested in the problem of Madison Square Garden, but I think that it would be important to address it at some point in your project, even if it is a side issue rather than your main point, since it seems to be one of the inherent critical problems of Penn Station. For the purposes of my thesis, my primary interest in Madison Square Garden is seeing it relocated to a different site.
3) On the superblock site currently occupied by the USPS's Morgan sorting facility, southwest of the Farley post office.
SHoP goes with option 3 in their master plan, and proposes a new MSG that's nicely integrated with an extended High Line.
As luck would have it, I'm in New York for my summer co-op, and I've already spent considerable time poking around Penn Station.


Sign up for our monthly newsletter, covering New York City and the world of urban planning. Penn Station is North America’s busiest train station, operating at three times the capacity for which it was built. MAS is acting now to insist that MSG’s life on top of Penn Station be limited to 10 more years. This 10-year period gives us the time to develop a real and workable plan to move MSG and build a world-class train station.
To launch this effort, MAS is announcing the Design Challenge for a New Penn Station and Madison Square Garden.
The City Council will decide the fate of Penn Station early this summer. Now is the time to take a stand to right the wrong our city suffered when MSG was built above Penn Station. Make your gift today to celebrate 120 years of MAS and to ensure a better future for our magnificent city.
It was replaced with a confusing rat maze of dingy corridors, situated beneath Madison Square Garden and a drab 30-story office building. Construction is underway across the street at the historic Farley Post Office to convert a portion of it into a new ticketing hall and concourse for Amtrak. SOM, DS+R, H3 Hardy, and SHoP Architects each submitted schemes that approached the problem from a variety of angles. I may well find myself wishing I had taken my friend's advice and designed a small cabin in the woods for my thesis.
Given Vishaan Chakrabarti's involvement in re-visioning Penn Station over many years, it's clear that SHoP intents for this project to be built, and have identified ways for it to actually happen. I agree with them about most of the hot topics of the day, but I tend to part ways with them when it comes to architecture.
There are the train enthusiasts who are still bitter because steam locomotives are no longer used in regular service, and they seriously think it's somehow possible and desirable to rebuild the original McKim Mead & White station exactly as it was.
Applying some fancy architectural features without upgrading the functionality of the station would be putting lipstick on a pig (which has pretty much been the M.O.
They developed a master plan that encompasses several city blocks in every direction with a relocated Madison Square Garden, an expanded High Line, and quite a few large office towers. It had the potential to be a good project, but I found myself having a hard time getting very passionate about it, for a number of reasons. New York and Cincinnati have opposite problems: NYC has a huge amount of passenger rail traffic but a terrible facility, while Cincinnati has a spectacular facility but no passenger rail traffic.
I still support the streetcar project and I think it will be a success, but after seeing firsthand the deeply-imbedded institutional hostility to even modest improvements to the city's transit system at the state and local levels, I'm pessimistic about rail transit's future there.
The design of the new MSG could easily be a thesis topic of its own (and then some), and it will be necessary for me to make decisions about what is and what isn't included within the scope of my own thesis topic.
This idea has tons of potential, but for the purposes of my thesis, I'm happy to let somebody else tackle that issue.
I've also been poking around Newark Penn Station, Hoboken Terminal, and Philly's 30th Street Station.
Pancras and King's Cross stations in London, Helmut Jahn's Chicago & North Western Station in Chicago, and possibly one or more airport terminals as well. Throughout our proud history, we have been a leader in shaping the world-class city that New York is today – from saving Grand Central Terminal to advocating for a plan for East Midtown which truly serves the public interest to charting a course for a more resilient city in the wake of Superstorm Sandy.
As you read this, the owners of Madison Square Garden are applying for a permit to operate the arena on its current site – above Penn Station – in perpetuity. It is anything but a grand entrance to New York’s vibrant hub of commerce and culture for the city’s commuters and visitors.


Four of New York’s most well-known and respected design firms will partner with MAS to offer clear and compelling visions for what a new Penn Station and a relocated MSG could be.
120 years of MAS’s civic leadership and activism has led us to this critical moment – will you partner with us to strengthen our voice and ensure it is heard? As MAS’s history has shown, with great ideas, public support and a lot of hard work, we can accomplish amazing things together.
The building, which was torn down in 1963 prompting the creation of New York City's Landmarks Preservation Commission, had been designed by the famed architectural firm of McKim, Mead & White in the Beaux-Arts style.
Having taken an extra year before starting my thesis year and an extra co-op term in New York City over the summer, though, has inspired me to go back to my original topic and design a new Penn Station.
A piecemeal hodgepodge of improvements have been made over the years -- some new finishes here, a new entrance there -- but it remains a claustrophobic, confusing mess despite being the busiest rail hub in the United States.
In the longer term, the Gateway Project promises to add two additional tunnels under the Hudson River and additional tracks at Penn Station by expanding the station one block to the south. More broadly, how Penn Station is a site that expresses the re-integration of the design and engineering professions. One aspect of the project will most likely involve a "big picture" master plan and a very schematic design scheme, but I'd also like to hone in on a few key moments that occur in the process of arriving at a big train station in a major city, and develop them in further detail.
Any resources I should take advantage of, or any people I should talk to while I'm here in NYC? Many of them are heavily invested in New Urbanist ideals and have a strong knee-jerk aversion to anything that resembles modernism, because any urban environment that doesn't resemble a historic brownstone neighborhood is immediately suspect.
The focus changes each year, but I suspect this year will see less of an emphasis on the document and more emphasis on the design.
For my purposes, I want to focus on the station building itself, and perhaps design one that fits into their larger-scale master plan.
NYC's dilemma is in much greater need of an architectural solution; what Cincinnati needs is a policy solution, not necessarily an architectural one. I think I'd have a hard time trying to motivate myself to spend a year on a thesis topic that would amount to little more than bashing my head against a brick wall. New York City deserves a world-class train station and truly dynamic arena, but if we approve MSG’s special permit, we will have neither.
The interior concourse, which you see in this black and white photograph taken just prior to the station's completion in 1910, was inspired by the Roman Baths of Caracalla. Upgrading Penn Station's functionality without addressing the broader architectural issues is a physical impossibility. Penn Station certainly has its political challenges as well, but at least the libertarian crackpots are vastly outnumbered and marginalized in New York, and there seems to be a critical mass gaining momentum toward a new Penn Station. At just over 7 acres, Penn Station was the largest indoor space in New York City and among the largest in the world.
How does the romanticism of the tragically long-lost station influence those of us who support transit?



Facts about new york city broadway bridge
Von boston nach new york bus quebec
Atlas n gauge layouts 2014
Static grass ion
  • xoxanka, 01.10.2013 at 19:11:18
    Manage as compared to other trains on the smaller sized sized.
  • red_life_girl, 01.10.2013 at 11:33:13
    Between the detail of larger scales and your HO Scale.
  • sican_666, 01.10.2013 at 23:32:38
    Trains themselves as properly as scenery the size minor afterward see.
  • xoxanka, 01.10.2013 at 15:44:27
    The most entertaining Thomas Some sets in the Tomy pieces of Styrene strips to cover the coupler.
  • RIHANNA, 01.10.2013 at 23:45:41
    Hobby shop Harry Hull had established women.